​

Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) Stock Forecast, Price Target & Predictions

OverviewRevenueOwnershipFinancialsChartTranscripts

SIGI Stock Forecast

Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) stock forecast, based on 16 Wall Street analysts, predicts a 12-month average price target of $83.75, with a high of $95.00 and a low of $73.00. This represents a 9.11% increase from the last price of $76.76.

$70 $78 $86 $94 $102 $110 High: $95 Avg: $83.75 Low: $73 Last Closed Price: $76.76

SIGI Stock Rating

Selective Insurance Group stock's rating consensus is Hold, based on 16 Wall Street analysts. The breakdown includes 0 Strong Buy (0.00%), 5 Buy (31.25%), 9 Hold (56.25%), 2 Sell (12.50%), and 0 Strong Sell (0.00%).

Hold
Total 16 0 2 9 5 Strong Sell Sell Hold Buy Strong Buy

SIGI Price Target Upside V Benchmarks

TypeNameUpside
StockSelective Insurance Group9.11%
SectorFinancial Services Stocks 12.59%
IndustryProperty & Casualty Insurance Stocks9.71%

Price Target Trends

1M3M12M
# Anlaysts-27
Avg Price Target-$82.50$82.00
Last Closing Price$76.76$76.76$76.76
Upside/Downside-7.48%6.83%
Ratings Trends
DateStrong BuyBuyHoldSellStrong SellTotal
Mar, 261141-7
Feb, 261141-7
Jan, 261151-8
Dec, 251151-8
Nov, 25-151-7
Analyst Price Target Forecasts
DateAnalystCompanyPrice TargetPrice when PublishedPrice Target/Price when PublishedPrice Target/Last Closing Price
Feb 02, 2026Piper Sandler$86.00$84.052.32%12.04%
Dec 22, 2025Piper Sandler$79.00$84.53-6.54%2.92%
Nov 24, 2025Rowland MayorRBC Capital$95.00$78.0621.70%23.76%
Oct 28, 2025Michael ZaremskiBMO Capital$81.00$76.875.37%5.52%
Oct 07, 2025Morgan Stanley$73.00$83.13-12.19%-4.90%
Aug 05, 2025Michael ZaremskiBMO Capital$88.00$78.0112.81%14.64%
Aug 05, 2025Morgan Stanley$72.00$78.01-7.70%-6.20%
Oct 30, 2024Michael ZaremskiBMO Capital$105.00$90.0516.60%36.79%
Oct 23, 2024Mark DwelleRBC Capital$99.00$93.326.09%28.97%
Oct 22, 2024Grace CarterBank of America Securities$102.00$96.975.19%32.88%
Analyst Rating Forecasts
DateCompanyPrevious RatingNew RatingRating Change
Feb 02, 2026Piper SandlerNeutralNeutralhold
Dec 22, 2025Piper SandlerNeutralNeutralhold
Nov 17, 2025Morgan StanleyUnderweightUnderweighthold
Oct 28, 2025BMO CapitalOutperformMarket Performdowngrade
Oct 07, 2025Morgan StanleyUnderweightUnderweighthold
Aug 05, 2025BMO CapitalOutperformOutperformhold
Aug 05, 2025Morgan StanleyMixedUnderweightdowngrade
May 19, 2025Morgan StanleyMixedMixedhold
Oct 30, 2024BMO CapitalMarket PerformOutperformupgrade
Oct 23, 2024RBC CapitalSector PerformSector Performhold

Financial Forecast

EPS Forecast

$3 $4 $5 $6 $7 $8 $9 $10 Dec 21 Dec 22 Dec 23 Dec 24 Dec 25 Dec 26
Dec 21Dec 22Dec 23Dec 24Dec 25Dec 26
Reported$6.55$3.57$5.87$3.25$7.48-
Avg Forecast$6.13$5.02$5.89$3.63$7.73$8.88
High Forecast$6.32$5.12$5.93$3.75$8.03$9.05
Low Forecast$6.04$4.95$5.85$3.45$7.39$8.77
Surprise %6.85%-28.88%-0.34%-10.47%-3.23%-

Revenue Forecast

$3B $4B $4B $5B $5B $6B Dec 21 Dec 22 Dec 23 Dec 24 Dec 25 Dec 26
Dec 21Dec 22Dec 23Dec 24Dec 25Dec 26
Reported$3.38B$3.56B$4.23B$4.86B$5.31B-
Avg Forecast$3.19B$3.51B$4.10B$4.66B$5.08B$5.47B
High Forecast$3.27B$3.56B$4.11B$4.67B$5.17B$5.65B
Low Forecast$3.15B$3.47B$4.03B$4.65B$5.00B$5.34B
Surprise %5.93%1.35%3.13%4.30%4.50%-

Net Income Forecast

$100M $200M $300M $400M $500M $600M Dec 21 Dec 22 Dec 23 Dec 24 Dec 25 Dec 26
Dec 21Dec 22Dec 23Dec 24Dec 25Dec 26
Reported$403.84M$224.89M$365.24M$207.01M$107.40M-
Avg Forecast$271.64M$298.80M$356.04M$227.13M$481.05M$536.60M
High Forecast$325.96M$358.56M$427.25M$228.90M$489.86M$552.01M
Low Forecast$217.31M$239.04M$284.83M$210.58M$450.79M$534.69M
Surprise %48.67%-24.74%2.58%-8.86%-77.67%-

SIGI Forecast FAQ

Is Selective Insurance Group stock a buy?

Selective Insurance Group stock has a consensus rating of Hold, based on 16 Wall Street analysts. The rating breakdown includes 0 Strong Buy, 5 Buy, 9 Hold, 2 Sell, and 0 Strong Sell, reflecting a consensus that Selective Insurance Group is a neutral investment for most analysts.

What is Selective Insurance Group's price target?

Selective Insurance Group's price target, set by 16 Wall Street analysts, averages $83.75 over the next 12 months. The price target range spans from $73 at the low end to $95 at the high end, suggesting a potential 9.11% change from the previous closing price of $76.76.

How does Selective Insurance Group stock forecast compare to its benchmarks?

Selective Insurance Group's stock forecast shows a 9.11% upside, underperforming the average forecast for the financial services stocks sector (12.59%) and underperforming the property & casualty insurance stocks industry (9.71%).

What is the breakdown of analyst ratings for Selective Insurance Group over the past three months?

  • March 2026: 14.29% Strong Buy, 14.29% Buy, 57.14% Hold, 14.29% Sell, 0% Strong Sell.
  • February 2026: 14.29% Strong Buy, 14.29% Buy, 57.14% Hold, 14.29% Sell, 0% Strong Sell.
  • January 2026: 12.50% Strong Buy, 12.50% Buy, 62.50% Hold, 12.50% Sell, 0% Strong Sell.

What is Selective Insurance Group’s EPS forecast?

Selective Insurance Group's average annual EPS forecast for its fiscal year ending in December 2026 is $8.88, marking a 18.72% increase from the reported $7.48 in 2025..

What is Selective Insurance Group’s revenue forecast?

Selective Insurance Group's average annual revenue forecast for its fiscal year ending in December 2026 is $5.47B, reflecting a 3.08% increase from the reported $5.31B in 2025.

What is Selective Insurance Group’s net income forecast?

Selective Insurance Group's net income forecast for the fiscal year ending in December 2026 stands at $536.6M, representing an 399.63% increase from the reported $107.4M in 2025.